[TERA PC & Console] En Masse is closing, but TERA lives on! We will continue to support TERA PC (NA) and TERA Console until service is transferred. Stay tuned for more information.
[TERA Console] The Grotto of Lost Souls update (v85) is now live! Read the patch notes here: https://bit.ly/TERACon_v85

[TERA PC] The 64-bit update (v97) is now live. Check out all the changes delivered on August 11 here: https://bit.ly/tera64_patchnotes
[TERA PC & CONSOLE] Summerfest Part 2: The Beach Bash is on from August 11 until September 1! Participate in event activities to earn tokens redeemable for costumes, consumables, mounts, and more! Details: https://bit.ly/tera_sf20

EME, please switch out items in the store on a more routine basis. .

13»

Comments

  • I have consistently said that the listing tax should be gone for everyone, and I've also consistently said over the years that the zero-listing fee was the one pay-to-win benefit of Elite -- but that doesn't mean the best answer is "now everyone pays a listing fee." Listing fees curtail trade, particularly when the game has other means of trade that involve no fees (and when they already have a problem with third-party programs adding "quality of life" features that could provide another means around the problem). If you want to prevent flipping/undercutting, there are other controls that could be used other than listing fees. And if BHS wants to control inflation, this method is unlikely to achieve the desired result.
    I'd be happy with the listing tax being gone for everyone as a preferred solution, but now that I've experienced what it's like to play TERA without Elite (after discontinuing my 5-year long subscription in protest of some...things), I have to say that Elite not having zero listing fee is infinitely preferable to Elite having this as an advantage over non-Elites.

    The issue with the zero listing fee is that it makes Elite required for selling expensive costumes. It means that if you don't have Elite, and open up a Elin Garment Box or something and got a dyeable pixie worth 750k, your excitement basically turns to horror when you realize you can't sell the damned thing because someone with Elite can always flip prices and undercut you whenever, and you can't undercut them back because it costs you like 38k gold to do so. For a new player, having to buy Elite just to sell a costume is incredibly off-putting and makes the game seem more exploitative than it already is.

    It's something you don't really realize until you actually break your subscription and start experiencing what it's like for players that don't have it. I know a lot of us have the $10 elite offer from a long time ago and don't want to discontinue it, but it's really hard to emphasize for the actual little guys until you do so. And yeah, sure, it does make Elite valuable, but I disagree with any optional subscription services that quite literally is "if you don't get this you're screwed (for selling expensive stuff)" rather than a lot of convenience features like it is now.
  • kamizumakamizuma ✭✭✭✭
    Serenade wrote: »
    I have consistently said that the listing tax should be gone for everyone, and I've also consistently said over the years that the zero-listing fee was the one pay-to-win benefit of Elite -- but that doesn't mean the best answer is "now everyone pays a listing fee." Listing fees curtail trade, particularly when the game has other means of trade that involve no fees (and when they already have a problem with third-party programs adding "quality of life" features that could provide another means around the problem). If you want to prevent flipping/undercutting, there are other controls that could be used other than listing fees. And if BHS wants to control inflation, this method is unlikely to achieve the desired result.
    I'd be happy with the listing tax being gone for everyone as a preferred solution, but now that I've experienced what it's like to play TERA without Elite (after discontinuing my 5-year long subscription in protest of some...things), I have to say that Elite not having zero listing fee is infinitely preferable to Elite having this as an advantage over non-Elites.

    The issue with the zero listing fee is that it makes Elite required for selling expensive costumes. It means that if you don't have Elite, and open up a Elin Garment Box or something and got a dyeable pixie worth 750k, your excitement basically turns to horror when you realize you can't sell the damned thing because someone with Elite can always flip prices and undercut you whenever, and you can't undercut them back because it costs you like 38k gold to do so. For a new player, having to buy Elite just to sell a costume is incredibly off-putting and makes the game seem more exploitative than it already is.

    It's something you don't really realize until you actually break your subscription and start experiencing what it's like for players that don't have it. I know a lot of us have the $10 elite offer from a long time ago and don't want to discontinue it, but it's really hard to emphasize for the actual little guys until you do so. And yeah, sure, it does make Elite valuable, but I disagree with any optional subscription services that quite literally is "if you don't get this you're screwed (for selling expensive stuff)" rather than a lot of convenience features like it is now.

    where are those expensive listed items now then?
  • > @kamizuma said:
    > where are those expensive listed items now then?

    In the hands of hoarders like yourself, of course ;p.

    Did you actually read my post?
  • kamizumakamizuma ✭✭✭✭
    Serenade wrote: »
    > @kamizuma said:
    > where are those expensive listed items now then?

    In the hands of hoarders like yourself, of course ;p.

    Did you actually read my post?

    Your post implied that having people undercut without drawbacks was discouraging non-elite players from listing their expensive items.
  • > @kamizuma said:
    > where are those expensive listed items now then?

    > @kamizuma said:
    > Serenade wrote: »
    >
    > > @kamizuma said:
    > > where are those expensive listed items now then?
    >
    > In the hands of hoarders like yourself, of course ;p.
    >
    > Did you actually read my post?
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > Your post implied that having people undercut without drawbacks was discouraging non-elite players from listing their expensive items.

    Yeah, and I figured you meant the general lack of supply, since you of all people know that it can take a long time for prices and matters to adjust. Vanguard's release had a month or two of arbitrage opportunities before the market fully adjusted.

    There are few new players in TERA due to all of EME's other policies, and they generally don't have high listing rates, so of course the supply isn't going to go back to before. That said, we'll need at least a few more weeks for people to get used to the shock to see what the long-term impacts actually are.

    And I did state in my first sentence that no broker fees for everyone is the ideal condition. I stand by this in place of making it elite only and driving more new players away to EU.
  • kamizumakamizuma ✭✭✭✭
    edited April 2019
    Serenade wrote: »
    > @kamizuma said:
    > where are those expensive listed items now then?

    > @kamizuma said:
    > Serenade wrote: »
    >
    > > @kamizuma said:
    > > where are those expensive listed items now then?
    >
    > In the hands of hoarders like yourself, of course ;p.
    >
    > Did you actually read my post?
    >
    >
    >
    >
    > Your post implied that having people undercut without drawbacks was discouraging non-elite players from listing their expensive items.

    Yeah, and I figured you meant the general lack of supply, since you of all people know that it can take a long time for prices and matters to adjust. Vanguard's release had a month or two of arbitrage opportunities before the market fully adjusted.

    There are few new players in TERA due to all of EME's other policies, and they generally don't have high listing rates, so of course the supply isn't going to go back to before. That said, we'll need at least a few more weeks for people to get used to the shock to see what the long-term impacts actually are.

    And I did state in my first sentence that no broker fees for everyone is the ideal condition. I stand by this in place of making it elite only and driving more new players away to EU.

    Nah the supply is definitely there but people (both elite and non-elite) are just heavily discouraged from listing expensive items on the broker. Instead it's become a game of "I hope I can catch the buyer/seller online while I spam for hours on end instead of actually playing the game". It's very obvious when looking at things like flying mounts, stormcry, rng-win items where their listed quantity has significantly decreased (10+ pages of stormcry to 1-2 now, 10+ pages of flying mounts to even just 5 listed now on kaiator lmao). As such, I ask again why aren't the non-elites (and even elites for that matter now since everyone is paying a fee) listing their stuff now since they don't have to fear constant undercut? This will not improve in the future simply because not many people want to risk their items not selling on the broker and losing their listing fee.

    No listing fee is of course the ideal solution but I still strongly believe that the previous (elite only) is infinitely better than it is now because with a mandatory listing fee, 75%+ of the items on the broker aren't even listed anymore (seriously, just compare broad categories of items before/after the change; for example elin costumes had 100+ pages before and now it's like 20) and most items that are still listed have actually gone up 25%+ in price. I have to admit though it's pretty fun undercutting people now and making them actually lose gold and changing item prices due to lack of competition so I guess there's that.
Sign In or Register to comment.