[TERA PC & Console] En Masse is closing, but TERA lives on! We will continue to support TERA PC (NA) and TERA Console until service is transferred. Stay tuned for more information.
[TERA Console] The Grotto of Lost Souls update (v85) is now live! Read the patch notes here: https://bit.ly/TERACon_v85

[TERA PC] The 64-bit update (v97) is now live. Check out all the changes delivered on August 11 here: https://bit.ly/tera64_patchnotes
[TERA PC & CONSOLE] Summerfest Part 2: The Beach Bash is on from August 11 until September 1! Participate in event activities to earn tokens redeemable for costumes, consumables, mounts, and more! Details: https://bit.ly/tera_sf20

Best tank?

If I play again I'm only doing PvE, and only tanking. What's the best tank currently? Don't give me that =^_^= pick your favorite garbage. What's the best by the numbers and ability to hold aggro?
«13456

Comments

  • edited September 2016
    to hold aggro its lancer if you wanna have dps and aggro brawler, anyway if you want just tank go lancer
  • Lancer is best tank, nuff said.
  • If aggro isn't an issue for anyone anymore then I would imagine Brawler would be best. However I'm not sure if a brawler has the capacity to hold a boss still like a lancer. Haven't played since their introduction.
  • vkobevkobe ✭✭✭✭✭
    =^_^= pick your favorite garbage

    brawler, it is alway party with crystal meth when you use brawler =^_^=
  • YamazukiYamazuki ✭✭✭✭✭
    Aggro is not a big deal anymore so that line of question doesn't need mentioning.

    What is best tank is silly and boring so I'll leave you with the option:

    Lancer: Supportive tank that brings DPS damage high. Your DPS needs to be good to take advantage of this. Best endurance debuff with -12%.

    Brawler: Self-centered tank that does high damage and consistent crits. Carry your DPS party if they suck. Need to be efficient with Growing Fury or else your damage contribution won't hold up that well. Endurance debuff is faster to stack up to 8%, but weaker than Lancer's 12%.

    If you just pug with unskilled parties then Brawler would be better. If you have a static/guildie/friends who are good at their DPS then Lancer would be better. If you suck at managing Growing Fury uptime then Lancer would be a better fit.

    Brawler has this stupid thing where it lags your computer the more you play with them. I was at Island of Dawn and noticed my fps dropped big time for strange reasons. Then I saw someone next to me fighting a BAM and it was a Brawler... lol

    Not sure what they were doing to lower your fps, although in dungeons if you're with a Brawler that can keep Growing Fury for the entire run around 90 seconds of it being up with constant attacks it will cause everyone's fps to drop down to nothing in some dungeons. If you encounter this ask the Brawler to stop attacking for ~2 seconds or if you're the Brawler then do that.
  • Yamazuki wrote: »
    Aggro is not a big deal anymore so that line of question doesn't need mentioning.

    What is best tank is silly and boring so I'll leave you with the option:

    Lancer: Supportive tank that brings DPS damage high. Your DPS needs to be good to take advantage of this. Best endurance debuff with -12%.

    Brawler: Self-centered tank that does high damage and consistent crits. Carry your DPS party if they suck. Need to be efficient with Growing Fury or else your damage contribution won't hold up that well. Endurance debuff is faster to stack up to 8%, but weaker than Lancer's 12%.

    If you just pug with unskilled parties then Brawler would be better. If you have a static/guildie/friends who are good at their DPS then Lancer would be better. If you suck at managing Growing Fury uptime then Lancer would be a better fit.

    Brawler has this stupid thing where it lags your computer the more you play with them. I was at Island of Dawn and noticed my fps dropped big time for strange reasons. Then I saw someone next to me fighting a BAM and it was a Brawler... lol

    Not sure what they were doing to lower your fps, although in dungeons if you're with a Brawler that can keep Growing Fury for the entire run around 90 seconds of it being up with constant attacks it will cause everyone's fps to drop down to nothing in some dungeons. If you encounter this ask the Brawler to stop attacking for ~2 seconds or if you're the Brawler then do that.

    off-topic, but is there proof of this? ive played brawler for a while now and i havent heard something so concrete as this
  • iunno I mean my pc not like PC elitist lvl

    never lag bc of another characters skillz

    think some ppl just run potatoes I mean a 2008 laptop Asus can play this game 4-5 settings
  • 1. #1 agro holder is zerker tank. But, zerker tank doesn't have infuriate.
    2. War and zerker tankers dps is weak. Lancer party and Brawler party clear dungeon faster than zerker/ War
    3. At +12 gear, brawler party clear faster than lancer.
    4. At +15 gear, brawler same as lancer party.
    5. lancer requires some low ping.
    6. War tank has worst agro.
    7. Brawler/ lancer solo faster than war/ zerker tank. It means, they clear dungeons faster.

    8. Lancer got the worst iframe among all classes. Lancer's backstep iframe time is already shortest and it gets even shorter with higher attack speed. Lancer is all good excpet 2 things. One is the backstep with very short iframe time. 2nd is, when FPS becomes low, Onslaught skill + shield bash combo pass through boss body.

    9. Brawler problem is - lack of 2nd dodge skill. Originally, 1st punch + counter skill was another good way to dodge attack. It's been nerfed and it's not even better than walking now. 2nd problem is perfect defense. Many brawlers don't care and use perfect defense. It's like lancer who nvr use any support skills in dungeon party. Brawler needs to learn how to use perfect defense.

    10. Lancer/ Brawler use lots mana pots. Lancer uses more. Don't try to save mana pots. It's cheap.
  • YamazukiYamazuki ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited September 2016
    Sametbh wrote: »

    off-topic, but is there proof of this? ive played brawler for a while now and i havent heard something so concrete as this
    Unfortunately I don't do any recording, but I know it's an issue with Growing Fury in particular. It doesn't happen in all instances either. The ones where I see it happen 100% of the time was DSL with it being somewhat an issue in DSU, MM, ABHM (where it gets really bad 2nd boss), and sometimes in SSHM. It's only an issue if you keep GF up for too long, for a really good group most bosses die too fast for it to be an issue. However, in slower runs where a Brawler can keep GF the entire time it eventually causes performance issue if they were attacking the entire time with no pause, which is what I do. It's something that was complained about before, and some people quit over it.

    Here's one thread of people complaining about it, where someone else also says if the Brawler stops attacking it will stop-> http://forums.enmasse.com/tera/discussion/comment/50413
  • KattyKiraKattyKira ✭✭
    edited September 2016
    Brawler also has a problem of being played badly in IMS parties, taking huge amounts of damage instead of dodging or blocking. This I don't see with lancer and zerker tanks, and the few warrior tanks I've healed also seem to get their dodges and blocks broken or mistimed badly.

    While clears maybe faster as brawler, I rather heal zerker and lancer tanks that block like a tank should. Ony a few brawlers tank properly in IMS, most runs I do with brawlers that I really enjoy are with friends that know how to time blocks and counters properly likemost lancers and some zerkers do. Less need to focus on healing the tank and more time focusing on debuffs and healing the fragile ninjas...

    Therefore, for me the best tank is a well played tank that knows how to time blocks properly and doesn't take insane amounts of damage expecting to be healed every second.
  • KiraboshiKiraboshi ✭✭✭
    edited September 2016
    Skilled team-
    Lancer > Brawler > Warrior >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Zerker

    Unskilled team-
    Brawler > Lancer > Warrior = Zerker

    Warrior is the hardest to tank well with, requires a very specific build, and doesn't make up for the difficulty with anything rewarding. Zerker doesn't have infuriate which auto-disqualifies Zerk tanks from any hardmode or serious endgame run.

    TL;DR of this entire thread: pick Lancer or Brawler.



  • ZoknahalZoknahal ✭✭✭✭✭
    streetdog wrote: »
    I seriously don't see what is wrong with zerk tanks.
    Because it's TERA. When there's a comparison between a class that takes a few seconds extra to defeat the boss, then that class that is slower is considered garbage and unplayable state. But it only takes one single video or dps meter to prove otherwise if someone is willing to do it, if not, then it's just under-represented.

    That only applies to those persons who are elitist to the extreme, and it also happens in every single mmo where you have multiple classes.

    Anyways, a lot of people already gave some good answers about the question at hand. I personally consider that Lancers are superior tanks, but that is just because i main a Lancer and have tried Brawler too, but it was not what i was expecting.

    If you wanna be the Tank that support the party with both offensive and defensive buffs, and is extremely durable, then your choice will be Lancer.

    If you however want to deal MORE damage (as of right now) than any pure DPS, roll your face on the keyboard and still be good, be the cancer of PvP, and overly feel like you are pro even tho all you do is use 3 skills out of like 15, without any extra effort and no gratification feeling that you did a good job, then you can go play Brawler. (my image of Brawlers is pretty damn low as of right now, sorry)

    Gotta warn you, Lancers takes more skill to play than Brawler, but many will disagree with me, specially those who main a Brawler. Brawlers ability to block while attacking makes em in my opinion too easy to play. Lancer is also depends a lot from low ping to play right.

    In the hands of a good player however, Lancers are superior. Even if you are a not so good player, or if you do not spend countless hours refining your skills, as long as you keep your priorities right, and do just basic skill rotation, you will be perfectly fine (at Brawler release, many of them totally dumped their role as a tank, and went full DPS just to be at the top of the DPS meter and increase their epeen, leading to wipes)
  • streetdog wrote: »
    I seriously don't see what is wrong with zerk tanks.

    They dont have infuriate.

    But imho, its negligible when pugging. I mean, how many pugs u've seen had enraged dmg crystals and rolls?
    I dont even infuriate unless the pug party specifically asked for it. Or I asked them first if they enraged-ready.
    Because before this, most of the time when i force enrage the boss in pug run, we got wiped. Enraged boss is extra stronk boss.
    Its different when LFG or guild run, because we'll be going in prepared, geared up and armed to the teeth.
    :3
  • YamazukiYamazuki ✭✭✭✭✭
    streetdog wrote: »
    1cf15e7214d44a323ce17410c39e6b66.png

    I seriously don't see what is wrong with zerk tanks.

    But yea, what any tank can do, lancer and brawler can do better. So they are far superior. With lancer being superior, because it provides more team utility. Team utility scales with the skill of the dps. Better dps the team has, more benefit they get from lancer. Not to mention that lancer already does as much as dps of brawler.

    People are mostly talking about when the classes are played by experienced players with low ping, even though 99% of the player base aren't going to ever achieve those results anyways, and as such the advantage a class might have becomes meaningless anyways... Then again, the whole copy the "pros" has been an issue for a long time in most games. Picking the 'best' class for any role kind of loses its meaning when you're not with a static group also doing the same thing or geared as well, so I honestly don't see why people won't just stick with what they enjoy, or what works for them.
  • As a main tank, that guy saying lancer is harder than brawl, you should really learn how to play brawl at a high level lol, lancer is fking easy to play, just need to block, push 4 buttons and done oh yeah buffs when burn, much wow. BTW i play brawl and lancer :) only problem on lancer is onslaught but you can do fine witout it. Go keep up a growing fury kthx. To come back to the question, Lancer or Brawler are both good. Lancer is just more party dependant.
Sign In or Register to comment.